THE PLOT:
The Phantom Thieves have won. The corrupt politician Shido has been defeated, as has the demon Yaldabaoth, and the Velvet Room has been restored.
So why have the Thieves suddenly all found themselves in a transformed version of the Velvet Room, redubbed as dance spot "Club Velvet"? Twin Velvet Room attendants Caroline and Justine inform the confused teens that they are to participate in a dance-off against their unseen sister's "guests," a competition that will be held in painstaking recreations of familiar settings, from the street of Tokyo to the various Palaces they have infiltrated to the depths of Mementos itself!
 |
| The Phantom Thieves are enlisted for a dancing competition. |
CHARACTERS:
Persona 5: Dancing in Starlight was developed jointly with Persona 3: Dancing in Moonlight... and given how much I liked that title, this one is extremely disappointing by comparison. The Persona 3 dancing game captured those characters beautifully - I'd argue, better than any of the other spinoffs that have featured them - while also finding ways to deepen the already strong original characterizations. This was one of many reasons why I found that dancing spinoff a surprise joy to play, and why I was genuinely looking forward to this one.
Sadly, with the exceptions of a couple good moments, the Persona 5 dancing game offers only one-note versions of these characters. Futaba ends up with the worst of it. In Persona 5, she was painfully uncomfortable with social interactions, but she was never deliberately rude or mean; even when she nicknamed Yusuke "Inari" after an anime villain, it quickly developed into a sort of semi-fond nickname. In Persona 5: Dancing in Starlight, Futaba is... obnoxious. When she is on the sidelines, she snaps at Yusuke to "shut your mouth hole!" - with a sharp, non-joking line delivery, and usually in response to perfectly innocuous comments. When she's onstage, she constantly chants, "Hype! Hype! Hype!" In short, a character who was likable in the main game has been turned into an active irritant.
The rest of the cast is more or less in character, but each Phantom Thief is reduced to just one or two traits. Morgana has a self-delusional crush on Ann; Makoto is a control freak; Ann is an airhead; and so on. An occasional moment will slip through that rings true, but these are too few and too far between.
 |
| Persona 5 protagonist Ren shares the stage with Ann. |
GAMEPLAY:
Gameplay here is identical to the other Persona dancing titles, which turns out to be this game's saving grace. As I observed in my reviews of Persona 3: Dancing in Moonlight and Persona 4: Dancing All Night, these games benefit from a remarkably intuitive interface. While the characters dance in rotoscoped animations, symbols float toward a ring at the edges of the screen. Some call for quick button prompts, others for holding a button in a slide, still others for moving one of the analog sticks to create a record scratch noise (this last can be reconfigured to be read by a press of the shoulder button instead). The simplicity does not negate a challenge; on higher difficulties, the variations in tempo and rapidly changing prompts will test your dexterity. It just means that the controls don't get in the way of you playing the game - and the core gameplay remains as addictive as it was in the other two dancing titles.
THOUGHTS:
I have been consistently impressed with the quality of the Persona series' various spinoffs. Even the ones I haven't liked have felt like legitimate expansions of the series rather than the cynical cash-ins I half-expected.
That trend had to break at some point, though. Persona 5: Dancing in Starlight is the first Persona spinoff that really feels like a cash grab. Sure, the gameplay is fun. But while the Persona 3 dancing game shone with love in its character interactions, this game... doesn't. Only a very few Social Links are actually interesting or effective, with the rest just feeling like hastily-scripted skits. Nothing is added to the characters or their relationships with each other, and few of the conversations are as enjoyable as the ones in the actual main game.
Added to that are the slim track offerings. Because this game was rushed out after Persona 5 proved to be a hit, it only features tracks and remixes of tracks from the core game. Nothing from Royal, or Q2, or Strikers. I like Life Will Change and Rivers in the Desert... but there are only so many variations on those that I'm actually interested in listening to. And while DLC tracks are available, most of them are taken from earlier games in the franchise.
I think this game fell victim to a rush to release. With the Persona 3 dancing game, more than a decade had passed since the release of even Persona 3 FES, and I think the creative team had new reflections on that set of characters. Here, Atlus had just released a 100+ hour game featuring the Persona 5 cast. With no distance between that game and this one, they can hardly be blamed for having nothing new to say about the characters. I strongly suspect this would be a stronger title altogether had they just waited a few more years.
 |
| The Phantom Thieves celebrate their bonds, |
OVERALL:
For all of my issues, Persona 5: Dancing in Starlight is not a bad game. The actual rhythm gameplay is as fun as ever; and while I wish there was a greater variety of Persona 5-specific tracks, I do like most of the music that's presented. Still, given how much I enjoyed the other two dancing spinoffs, I can't help but feel disappointed about how bland this one ends up. Since this was developed jointly with the Persona 3 dancing game, it seems clear that - likely unintentionally - the developers put more heart and effort into that game than they did into this one.
Overall Rating: 4/10.
Previous Game: Persona 5
Next Game: Persona Q2 - New Cinema Labyrinth
Review Index
To receive new review updates, follow me:
On BlueSky:
On Threads:
